Training health professionals without available jobs and/or placement opportunities can have several significant impacts both on the trainees and the government, and these impacts range from personal, through economic, social, healthcare system to policies.
Economic Impacts
Wasted Investment:
Both governments and individuals invest heavily in the training of health professionals. Without job and placement opportunities, these investments yield no return, leading to economic inefficiency. When the economy becomes inefficient, government officials resort to other ways to raise budgets to run the affairs of the country. This might include increase of the cost of some public services including school fees, increase taxes, etc.
The greatest burden unfortunately is on the trainees and their families, especially in an economy with lot of hardship. Most students have their parents staff every day, toy their fingers to the bones, and have their property confiscated because they took some loans but couldn't pay back.
After spending much and having accumulated much debt, some students simply drop out while others 'pause' their studies to turn to other revenue generating activities.
Student/Family Debt:
Many health professionals and/or their families accumulate significant debt during their education, considering that professional education in low-income countries is still very expensive, and this includes cost of books, fees, housing, food and other bills. Most students and parents sacrifice a lot to have this education, hoping that after graduation they would pick up a good job and clear their debts in a few months or years. Without employment and placement opportunities, they may struggle to repay these loans, affecting their financial stability.
Unemployment and Underemployment:
Trained professionals may remain unemployed or take jobs below their qualification levels, leading to underemployment and reduced economic productivity. Some drop completely from school during their final years, others, after graduation simply get the next available jobs from other fields, just to make ends meet. This creates both underemployment and ineffectiveness in their new jobs because they were not trained in the field.
Social Impacts
Brain Drain:
Highly skilled professionals may migrate to other regions or countries where jobs are available, resulting in a loss of talent and weak economy in the home country.
Today, many health professionals of all ages are migrating to countries like Canada, USA, Francs, because great opportunities and jobs are readily available.
Social Discontent:
Frustration and dissatisfaction among unemployed professionals can lead to social unrest and a decrease in the overall morale of the workforce. Crimes rate increase due to depression and illegal practices which do not align with government policies and professional ethics.
Community Health Impact:
Communities may miss out on the potential health benefits that these professionals could provide if employed effectively, leading to a continued gap in healthcare services.
Personal Impacts
Mental Health Issues: The stress and frustration of not finding suitable employment can lead to mental health issues such as anxiety and depression among health professionals.
Skill Atrophy:
Prolonged periods of unemployment can lead to skill deterioration, making it even harder for professionals to find jobs in the future.
Career Changes:
Some professionals may eventually leave the health sector altogether, leading to a loss of trained individuals in the field.
Healthcare System Impacts
Misalignment of Supply and Demand:
Overproduction of health professionals in certain fields can result in a mismatch between supply and demand, exacerbating existing workforce imbalances.
Resource Allocation:
Resources used in training professionals who cannot find jobs could have been allocated more efficiently, such as improving existing healthcare infrastructure or training professionals in high-demand specialties.
Patient Drain into the Quarters:
Well trained unemployed health professionals remain great competitors to the healthcare facilities. Becasue they have no funds to set up legal health facilities, they are obliged to turn to clandestine practice in their immediate communities. They need to pay debts accumulated during their training career; they need to feed themselves and their parents; they need to get their basic needs. This is a very common pratice in societies where there is increase economic hardship, not only on the side of the professional, but also on the side of the patients. Talking to some patients who receive clandestine care one had this to say.
Unlike in the hospital where I will pay a consultation fee when I don't even have the money, wait in the qeue for hours, have the doctor talk to you any how, and laboratory examinations for 50s of thousands, I just prefer receiving my treatment in my quarter. My doctor is very respectful and available.
Based on the above, there is therefor no doubt that in the nearest future the increasing numbers of these unemployed professionals might just retain most patients in the quarters, leaving legal health facilities with just critical cases.
Policy Implications
Workforce Planning:
There is a need for better workforce planning and forecasting to align training programs with labor market needs.
Job Creation:
Governments and healthcare organizations need to create more job opportunities and consider policies that encourage the retention of health professionals.
Education Reforms:
Educational institutions may need to adjust their programs to match the current and future demands of the healthcare sector.
Recommendations
Conduct Regular Labor Market Analysis: Regularly analyze the labor market to understand the demand for various health professions and adjust training programs accordingly.
Increase Funding for Healthcare Jobs: Increase funding to create more positions in the healthcare sector, especially in underserved areas.
Promote Job Matching Programs: Develop job matching programs that connect newly trained professionals with employers.
Encourage Diverse Career Paths: Encourage health professionals to explore diverse career paths within the healthcare sector that might be in demand but less known.
By addressing these impacts and implementing strategic solutions, it is possible to ensure that the training of health professionals leads to meaningful employment and improved healthcare outcomes.
Please, let us have your opinion on this subject. React to this post and leave us a comment below before leaving. Most importantly, tell the story by sharing as well. Thank you!
Thanks for reading. Please let's have your opinion in this comment section.